Michael Polly
Royal Shell Real Estate
- Address : 959 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel Island,United States
About
Michael has earned the ePRO, Graduate Real Estate Institute (GRI) and is a licensed USCG Captain. Michael became the first Realtor in SW Florida and the 11th in the state to earn his Accredited Seller Representative (ASR). This designation is awarded based on both actual performance and required education. The first awarded in SW Florida. Michael has completed the education and training necessary to earn his Certified Property Valuator (CPV), only the second awarded in Lee County. He offers Broker Price Opinions as part of his advanced service to his clients. Most recently Michael has completed advanced training and work review and is now certified by National Valuations Standards Institute. Michael has also earned his (CDPE) Certified Distressed Property Expert to assist buyers and sellers with bank owned foreclosures and short sale properties. Michael worked for 15 years with UPS in a variety of roles. His training and management of projects helped him build his own business.
Contact
$2,995,000
5Beds
5.1Baths
4,169Sqft
Fort Myers, Florida, 33908, United States
Located in the highly sought-after St. Charles Harbour, this newer construction residence is one of the newest homes built in the community and offers exceptional design, privacy, and quality throughout. Built by one of the most well-respected builders in the area, Harbourside Custom Homes, your assured a home that stands the test of time.
Michael Polly
$2,995,000
15801 Chatfield Drive
Fort Myers, Florida, 33908, United States
Located in the highly sought-after St. Charles Harbour, this newer construction residence is one of the newest homes built in the community and offers exceptional design, privacy, and quality throughout. Built by one of the most well-respected builders in the area, Harbourside Custom Homes, your assured a home that stands the test of time. As you enter the home your greeted by a beautiful solid mahogany front door, making a striking first impression, welcoming you into a light and bright interior with soaring 12–14 ft ceilings, detailed beams, and soft neutral tones. Featuring 5 bedrooms plus a den and 5.5 baths, every bedroom is en-suite and thoughtfully arranged in a split floor plan to provide privacy for both owners and guests. The home offers a 3-car oversized garage, including a 28-foot-deep bay for two vehicles, and is pre-wired for a generator with dual 50-amp direct-plug connections. Impact glass is installed throughout, along with cameras on every corner, commercial-grade Wi-Fi, and a whole-home Kinetico water softener and filtration system. The open, well-designed floor plan centers around a stunning kitchen with high-end Thermador appliances, a butler’s pantry, and a formal dining area. The kitchen flows seamlessly into the spacious family room featuring custom built-ins and elegant ceiling details, creating a calm, relaxing atmosphere perfect for family and friends. The expansive owner’s suite includes a sitting area overlooking the preserve, two large walk-in closets, and a spa-like bath with dual vanities. Four additional guest suites each offer their own private baths, ensuring comfort for everyone. Step outside to a massive screened picture-window lanai backing to a private preserve, complete with a beautiful pool and spa, plus plumbing already in place for an outdoor kitchen. St. Charles Harbour features an active Yacht Club with a popular waterfront restaurant just down the street, along with the opportunity to purchase or lease marina slips with quick access to the Gulf and Intracoastal waterways—offering some of the best boating in Florida. Built to the newest codes and elevation standards, this home delivers luxury, peace of mind, and an exceptional coastal lifestyle.
Read More
Michael Polly
$2,995,000
15801 Chatfield Drive
5Beds
5.1Baths
4,169Sqft
$2,995,000
Fort Myers, Florida, 33908, United States
$2,990,000
7Beds
7Baths
5,830Sqft
Williston, Florida, 32696, United States
Gorgeous 30 acre horse farm with custom build main house, guest house, barn, 2 apartments, & 14 paddocks! This 30 acre property is well located less than 10 mins to the HITS show grounds & 20 mins to the World Equestrian Center & has two separate gated entrances.
Michael Polly
$2,990,000
19331 E LEVY STREET
Williston, Florida, 32696, United States
Gorgeous 30 acre horse farm with custom build main house, guest house, barn, 2 apartments, & 14 paddocks! This 30 acre property is well located less than 10 mins to the HITS show grounds & 20 mins to the World Equestrian Center & has two separate gated entrances. The elegantly appointed 3 bedroom/ 3 full bath plus office main house has a 3 car attached garage & many high end upgrades throughout & is accessed through a gated entry. The gourmet kitchen boasts stone counter tops, double ovens, wine frig, 6-burner gas cook top, large island & huge walk-in pantry. The primary bedroom is over- sized with sitting area & direct access to the covered patio. The en-suite 5- piece primary bathroom has a generous walk-in shower & the adjoining walk-in closet is oversized with built-in shelving & a large island w/ cabinets. The adjacent large detached shop/garage has water & electric & the property boasts a propane generator, 500 gallon propane tank, tankless propane water heaters & an exterior camera system. The guest house & barn have a separate gated entry & the entire farm is fully fenced. The 2-bedroom guest house is also concrete block construction, has 2 full bathrooms, over-sized primary bedroom walk in closet, has been updated with tile flooring throughout, & kitchen was updated with newer soft close cabinets & stone counter tops. The well-designed block barn was built in 2012 with many high-end amenities including 6, 12’ x 12’ stalls with the comfort stall systems & auto waters, 2 wash stalls with hot water, roll up hurricane doors, grooming stall, & a tack room & feed room. There is also a separate hay room. There are two barn apartments- a 1 bedroom/ 1 full bathroom & a studio with private bathroom. The paddocks have water & shelter in each & there are also 2, 50-amp rv hook ups & a large pole barn with electric & water. The property has 4 wells that are connected w/ water softener systems. The property consists of 3 parcels & can also be purchased as two separate parcels with a house on each- see listings OM713622 & OM713620.
Read More
Michael Polly
$2,990,000
19331 E LEVY STREET
7Beds
7Baths
5,830Sqft
$2,990,000
Williston, Florida, 32696, United States
$2,950,000
2.42Sqft
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
Magnificent 2 acre plus beachfront estate within the desirable and exclusive Gulf Ridge community. If privacy is important this oversized gem offers a beautiful island setting combining a beautiful beachfront ambiance with nightly sunsets. Terrific private beach access. Community pool and tennis. Located nearby conservation owned lands, Ding Darling and Sanctuary Golf Club.
Michael Polly
$2,950,000
5085 Joewood Dr
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
Magnificent 2 acre plus beachfront estate within the desirable and exclusive Gulf Ridge community. If privacy is important this oversized gem offers a beautiful island setting combining a beautiful beachfront ambiance with nightly sunsets. Terrific private beach access. Community pool and tennis. Located nearby conservation owned lands, Ding Darling and Sanctuary Golf Club. 5085 Joewood Drive is surrounded by the attractive natural beauty that only the island’s hold.
Read More
Michael Polly
$2,950,000
3Beds
3Baths
3,053Sqft
Ocala, Florida, 34482, United States
PRIVATE/OWNER FINANCING Options available for qualified purchasers. Just minutes from the World Equestrian Center and Golden Ocala Golf & Equestrian Club, this extraordinary 2023-built estate presents a rare convergence of modern architectural elegance and world-class equestrian functionality, all set across nearly 11 impeccably manicured acres behind private gates.
Michael Polly
$2,950,000
11098 NW 50TH LANE
Ocala, Florida, 34482, United States
PRIVATE/OWNER FINANCING Options available for qualified purchasers. Just minutes from the World Equestrian Center and Golden Ocala Golf & Equestrian Club, this extraordinary 2023-built estate presents a rare convergence of modern architectural elegance and world-class equestrian functionality, all set across nearly 11 impeccably manicured acres behind private gates. Designed for the discerning equestrian, the property features a professional 105 x 150 riding arena with premium clay footing, four spacious barn stalls, an air-conditioned tack room, and dual wash racks, all thoughtfully positioned for efficiency, comfort, and horse welfare. Fully fenced and irrigated pastures and paddocks with water throughout provide an ideal environment for training, turnout, and long-term care, while two gated entrances ensure privacy, security, and seamless access for trailers and service vehicles. The residence itself is a striking expression of refined contemporary design, featuring three bedrooms, three baths, and a private executive office with a temperature-controlled wine room. Soaring ceiling heights, from 12 feet in the main living spaces to nearly 19 feet in the great room, create an atmosphere of light, volume, and architectural drama. Kolbe crank windows, custom window treatments, and sleek tile flooring throughout reflect a polished yet relaxed aesthetic tailored to the equestrian lifestyle. At the heart of the home, the chef’s kitchen is both functional and beautiful, appointed with quartz countertops, custom cabinetry, an Elica designer hood, Café gas range with pot filler, an oversized pantry, and a dedicated mudroom designed for life both in and out of the saddle. The great room is anchored by a dramatic gas fireplace and enhanced by a fully integrated Sonos surround-sound system with zoned audio extending throughout the home and outdoor living spaces. The primary suite is a serene private retreat, featuring elegant chandelier lighting, dual oversized walk-in closets, and a spa-inspired bath with a temperature-controlled shower designed for true relaxation after a day at the barn or the showgrounds. Technically, the estate is as advanced as it is beautiful, featuring a whole-home generator with a buried 1,000-gallon propane tank, 400-amp electrical service, fiber-optic internet infrastructure, dual high-efficiency HVAC systems with Icynene insulation, and a three-car garage designed to accommodate larger vehicles and trailers with a European-style door system. Outdoor living is nothing short of resort-caliber. A screened lanai with electric Phantom screens creates a cool, breezy environment that opens to a heated and chilled pool, summer kitchen, and fire pit, ideal for elegant entertaining or quiet evenings overlooking the grounds. The entire property is fully irrigated with precision Fibernom drip systems for lush landscaping year-round, and an advanced multi-camera security system covers both the residence and barn for complete peace of mind. Every detail of this estate has been thoughtfully curated to deliver a rare combination of privacy, performance, luxury, and proximity, creating a truly turnkey equestrian lifestyle just moments from Ocala’s most sought-after destinations.
Read More
Michael Polly
$2,950,000
11098 NW 50TH LANE
3Beds
3Baths
3,053Sqft
$2,950,000
Ocala, Florida, 34482, United States
$2,950,000
3Beds
3.1Baths
3,286Sqft
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
Nestled on a coveted deep-water canal basin on Sanibel Island, 877 Limpet Dr. is a boater’s paradise with luxury throughout. This elevated 3,286 sq. ft. home, remodeled in 2019 by Kennedy Const., blends modern elegance with functionality. This home is on a concrete seawall and boasts a 45ft slip designed for a 30K lb. lift, an adjacent 10K lb.
Michael Polly
$2,950,000
877 Limpet Drive
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
Nestled on a coveted deep-water canal basin on Sanibel Island, 877 Limpet Dr. is a boater’s paradise with luxury throughout. This elevated 3,286 sq. ft. home, remodeled in 2019 by Kennedy Const., blends modern elegance with functionality. This home is on a concrete seawall and boasts a 45ft slip designed for a 30K lb. lift, an adjacent 10K lb. lift for a fishing boat, and a 3-car-sized boat trailer garage alongside a 3-car-plus garage, both with A/C storage. Enjoy direct, no-bridge Gulf access in just 5 min. and with the services of the Sanibel Marina only 500 yds away, adventures begin at your doorstep. Inside, a great room opens to a chef’s kitchen with custom cabinetry and waterside dining area, perfect for entertaining. Other key features include European white oak floors, impact windows, powered storm shutters, a spacious rec area, pool, patio, and deeded beach parking and access a mile away. Additionally, this home has a 24KW Generac generator with two propane takes totaling 1250 gal. The 45 foot boat slip was designed for a 30K lift and has a pedestal with (2) 30amp and (2) 20amp outlets. The existing 10K lb. lift adjacent to slip has (2) 15amp outlets. Lower level has 3 mini-split units for A/C. Located on Sanibels East end, this home is just 550 yards from Sanibels Causeway Blvd and 1.5 miles from the Sanibel Lighthouse. Explore 25 miles of bike paths and J.N. Ding Darling Refuge. This waterfront gem offers unmatched design and boating amenities!
Read More
Michael Polly
$2,950,000
877 Limpet Drive
3Beds
3.1Baths
3,286Sqft
$2,950,000
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
$2,950,000
3Beds
0.1Baths
4,854Sqft
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
Nestled on a coveted deep-water canal basin on Sanibel Island, 877 Limpet Dr. is a boater’s paradise with luxury throughout. This elevated 3,286 sq. ft. home, remodeled in 2019 by Kennedy Const., blends modern elegance with functionality. This home is on a concrete seawall and boasts a 45ft slip designed for a 30K lb. lift, an adjacent 10K lb.
Michael Polly
$2,950,000
877 Limpet Dr
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
Nestled on a coveted deep-water canal basin on Sanibel Island, 877 Limpet Dr. is a boater’s paradise with luxury throughout. This elevated 3,286 sq. ft. home, remodeled in 2019 by Kennedy Const., blends modern elegance with functionality. This home is on a concrete seawall and boasts a 45ft slip designed for a 30K lb. lift, an adjacent 10K lb. lift for a fishing boat, and a 3-car-sized boat trailer garage alongside a 3-car-plus garage, both with A/C storage. Enjoy direct, no-bridge Gulf access in just 5 min. and with the services of the Sanibel Marina only 500 yds away, adventures begin at your doorstep. Inside, a great room opens to a chef’s kitchen with custom cabinetry and waterside dining area, perfect for entertaining. Other key features include European white oak floors, impact windows, powered storm shutters, a spacious rec area, pool, patio, and deeded beach parking and access a mile away. Additionally, this home has a 24KW Generac generator with two propane takes totaling 1250 gal. The 45 foot boat slip was designed for a 30K lift and has a pedestal with (2) 30amp and (2) 20amp outlets. The existing 10K lb. lift adjacent to slip has (2) 15amp outlets. Lower level has 3 mini-split units for A/C. Located on Sanibels East end, this home is just 550 yards from Sanibels Causeway Blvd and 1.5 miles from the Sanibel Lighthouse. Explore 25 miles of bike paths and J.N. Ding Darling Refuge. This waterfront gem offers unmatched design and boating amenities!
Read More
Michael Polly
$2,895,000
3Beds
2Baths
2,250Sqft
Marco Island, Florida, 34145, United States
UNIQUE OPPORTUNITY This is more than just a home, its an invitation to experience the ultimate island lifestyle in a thriving, upscale neighborhood. This water front home located on an oversized lot in the impressive Tigertail neighborhood on Marco Island is deep water direct that allows for a larger vessel. Where you can walk, bike or boat to one of our fine shops and restaurants.
Michael Polly
$2,895,000
609 CRESCENT STREET
Marco Island, Florida, 34145, United States
UNIQUE OPPORTUNITY This is more than just a home, its an invitation to experience the ultimate island lifestyle in a thriving, upscale neighborhood. This water front home located on an oversized lot in the impressive Tigertail neighborhood on Marco Island is deep water direct that allows for a larger vessel. Where you can walk, bike or boat to one of our fine shops and restaurants. This elegant home offers a neutral pallet with 3 bedroom 2 baths including an office. Enjoy spacious open split floor plan with high ceilings, large rooms including a family room, sitting room, dining room, breakfast nook, large stone island, fully equipped kitchen, and bahama shutters. The primary suite offers tray ceilings, large stone shower, two closets and two vanities. The back of the house is a wall of windows that overlook the salt water lap pool with panoramic screen. The spacious pool deck is ready for entertaining with a firepit table, sectional and dining table. You can lounge on the deck below alongside the dock with two boat slips. Very well maintained property. The flat tile roof and stylish pavers adorn the driveway that take you to the large garage with ample storage, high ceilings, 3 bays with an epoxy floor. Professionally decorated, lush landscape, hurricane roll downs, generator on a transfer switch, security system and offered turn key. A fantastic opportunity! A ready made island lifestyle in a neighborhood with new elegant modern estate homes. Marco Island is an active lifestyle. Famous for our crescent beach with sugar sand, easy boating, great golf, tennis, cuisine from around the world and the best sunsets on the planet. This truly is the ULTIMATE PACKAGE.
Read More
Michael Polly
$2,895,000
609 CRESCENT STREET
3Beds
2Baths
2,250Sqft
$2,895,000
Marco Island, Florida, 34145, United States
$2,799,000
4Beds
4.1Baths
6,218Sqft
Dunnellon, Florida, 34432, United States
Elegant 19 acre estate style farm in the gated Equestrian Community of Bel Lago, well located close the World Equestrian Center & shopping. This gorgeous horse farm boasts a custom built 6200 sq ft pool home with a guest casita, 4-stall center aisle barn, large grass paddocks & nearby riding trails.
Michael Polly
$2,799,000
12450 SW 140TH LOOP
Dunnellon, Florida, 34432, United States
Elegant 19 acre estate style farm in the gated Equestrian Community of Bel Lago, well located close the World Equestrian Center & shopping. This gorgeous horse farm boasts a custom built 6200 sq ft pool home with a guest casita, 4-stall center aisle barn, large grass paddocks & nearby riding trails. The resort-style pool area overlooks the acreage & oak trees & has travertine decking & a large screened-in lanai with summer kitchen & fireplace. The home boasts luxurious high-end finishes throughout & has 4 bedrooms, 5 bathrooms plus two offices. Each bedroom has an en-suite bathroom for privacy. The gourmet kitchen has an enormous island overlooking the family room & lanai with plenty of space to entertain. The expansive primary suite is located on the main floor with 2 large walk in closets & a spa-like en suite bathroom. The home also has a large open loft area on the second floor with a balcony overlooking the grounds, in addition to the two guest bedrooms with bathrooms. Enjoy the Florida lifestyle by the beautiful pool and outdoor living area complete with a summer kitchen and fireplace. The private casita is located by the pool & is perfect for guests or a mother-in-law suite. There is a 3 car garage with additional washer & dryer & partially finished loft area above the garage for storage. Bring your horses & move right in to this elegant 19 acre estate!
Read More
Michael Polly
$2,799,000
12450 SW 140TH LOOP
4Beds
4.1Baths
6,218Sqft
$2,799,000
Dunnellon, Florida, 34432, United States
$2,795,000
3Beds
2Baths
2,250Sqft
Marco Island, Florida, 34145, United States
This is more than just a home, its an invitation to experience the ultimate island lifestyle in a thriving, upscale neighborhood. This water front home located on an oversized lot in the Prestigious Tigertail neighborhood on Marco Island is deep water direct that allows for a larger vessel. Where you can walk, bike or boat to one of our fine shops and restaurants.
Michael Polly
$2,795,000
609 Crescent Street
Marco Island, Florida, 34145, United States
This is more than just a home, its an invitation to experience the ultimate island lifestyle in a thriving, upscale neighborhood. This water front home located on an oversized lot in the Prestigious Tigertail neighborhood on Marco Island is deep water direct that allows for a larger vessel. Where you can walk, bike or boat to one of our fine shops and restaurants. This elegant home offers a neutral pallet with 3 bedroom 2 baths including an office. Enjoy spacious open split floor plan with high ceilings, large rooms including a family room, sitting room, dining room, breakfast nook, large stone island, fully equipped kitchen, and bahama shutters. The primary suite offers tray ceilings, large stone shower, two closets with two vanities. The back of the house is a wall of windows that overlook the salt water lap pool with panoramic screen. The spacious pool deck is ready for entertaining with a firepit table, sectional and dining table. You can lounge on the deck below alongside the dock with two boat slips. Very well maintained property. The flat tile roof and stylish pavers adorn the driveway that take you to the large garage with ample storage, high ceilings with3 bays and epoxy floor. Professionally decorated, lush landscape, hurricane roll downs, generator on a transfer switch, security system and offered turn key. This a fantastic opportunity! A ready made island lifestyle in a neighborhood with new elegant modern estate homes. Marco Island is an active lifestyle. Famous for our crescent beach with sugar white sand, easy boating, great golf, tennis, cuisine from around the world and the best sunsets on the planet.
Read More
Michael Polly
$2,795,000
609 Crescent Street
3Beds
2Baths
2,250Sqft
$2,795,000
Marco Island, Florida, 34145, United States
$2,750,000
4Beds
7,168Sqft
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
A truly special and unique island jewel, this exceptional East End Sanibel retreat offers a rare blend of refined island living, advanced technology and resort-style amenities. The property features a three-bedroom main residence, graceful indoor/outdoor living under one roof with a separate one-bedroom en-suite guest house, thoughtfully designed for flexibility, comfort, and modern performance.
Michael Polly
$2,750,000
687 Anchor Dr
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
A truly special and unique island jewel, this exceptional East End Sanibel retreat offers a rare blend of refined island living, advanced technology and resort-style amenities. The property features a three-bedroom main residence, graceful indoor/outdoor living under one roof with a separate one-bedroom en-suite guest house, thoughtfully designed for flexibility, comfort, and modern performance. Nestled within a private and intimate tropical setting, the home is surrounded by mature landscaping and curated exterior resort lighting and just steps away from private beach access and the home’s own 8,000-lb boat lift with floating kayak platform—creating a seamless connection between land and sea. A private resort lifestyle awaits. The residence is equipped with a hurricane-proven 21.465kW DC solar array and 30kWh battery storage system providing full backup and capable of powering the entire home 24/7. The property is EV-ready, with multiple EV chargers in the garage on dedicated circuits and power in place for dockside EV charging. The garage offers oversized impact-rated doors, impact windows and two four-post vehicle lifts. The guest house includes a dedicated luxury gym and wellness space featuring lifting floors and commercial-grade surfaces. Naturally aged, untreated ipe decking is featured throughout, including the covered porch, stairs, and boat dock. The elegant board-and-batten poly-ash exterior cladding showcases the architecture, complemented by hurricane-proven GulfLok metal roofing system installed in 2020. The custom heated saltwater pool is designed specifically for lap swimming and includes a fully retractable automated cover, offering both safety and insulation benefits. This exceptional property sets a new standard for modern island living—where privacy, sustainability, and luxury converge in perfect harmony.
Read More
Michael Polly
$2,749,400
3Beds
2.1Baths
3,393Sqft
Ocala, Florida, 34482, United States
Step into an elevated lifestyle with this pristine, recently built 2024 residence — a true trophy property offering 3,393 sq. ft. of refined living across a generous 0.32-acre lot. This is luxury redefined: tailored for discerning buyers who appreciate space, craftsmanship, and the promise of days spent in comfort and style.
Michael Polly
$2,749,400
8095 NW 29TH STREET ROAD
Ocala, Florida, 34482, United States
Step into an elevated lifestyle with this pristine, recently built 2024 residence — a true trophy property offering 3,393 sq. ft. of refined living across a generous 0.32-acre lot. This is luxury redefined: tailored for discerning buyers who appreciate space, craftsmanship, and the promise of days spent in comfort and style. This home offers thoughtful design from room to room with generous entertaining space. An added bonus is the location of this magnificent property, located perfectly on the 9th fairway overlooking beautiful and lush fairways with mature trees. This home is far more than bricks and beams, but a unique opportunity to enjoy your moments in peace and serenity. An added benefit is the proximity to the Spa, Tennis and Restaurant located just a few steps from your home. ***Possibility of a rental could be an option as well***
Read More
Michael Polly
$2,749,400
8095 NW 29TH STREET ROAD
3Beds
2.1Baths
3,393Sqft
$2,749,400
Ocala, Florida, 34482, United States
$2,700,000
10,006Sqft
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
Income-producing two-story commercial building in the heart of Sanibel’s Central Business District, offering 175 feet of prime Palm Ridge Road frontage and outstanding visibility. Zoned Town Center Limited, the preferred location for retail and mixed-use opportunities, and is designated G (Altered Lands) under the City of Sanibel Comprehensive Land Use Plan.
Michael Polly
$2,700,000
2440 Palm Ridge Rd
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
Income-producing two-story commercial building in the heart of Sanibel’s Central Business District, offering 175 feet of prime Palm Ridge Road frontage and outstanding visibility. Zoned Town Center Limited, the preferred location for retail and mixed-use opportunities, and is designated G (Altered Lands) under the City of Sanibel Comprehensive Land Use Plan. The fully leased first floor provides immediate, stable cash flow, while each level offers 4,066 square feet of space. Constructed with steel-reinforced concrete slab and concrete stem wall footings for long-term durability and low maintenance. The second floor presents future residential potential, with architectural plans already prepared and subject to City approval—creating meaningful value-add and additional income upside. A strategic opportunity to secure high-visibility Sanibel commercial real estate with both current performance and long-term growth potential.
Read More
Michael Polly
Favorite this home
Enter your email to continue
or
By signing in you agree to UniqueHomes Terms of Use and Privacy Policy