Michael Polly
Royal Shell Real Estate
- Address : 959 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel Island,United States
About
Michael has earned the ePRO, Graduate Real Estate Institute (GRI) and is a licensed USCG Captain. Michael became the first Realtor in SW Florida and the 11th in the state to earn his Accredited Seller Representative (ASR). This designation is awarded based on both actual performance and required education. The first awarded in SW Florida. Michael has completed the education and training necessary to earn his Certified Property Valuator (CPV), only the second awarded in Lee County. He offers Broker Price Opinions as part of his advanced service to his clients. Most recently Michael has completed advanced training and work review and is now certified by National Valuations Standards Institute. Michael has also earned his (CDPE) Certified Distressed Property Expert to assist buyers and sellers with bank owned foreclosures and short sale properties. Michael worked for 15 years with UPS in a variety of roles. His training and management of projects helped him build his own business.
Contact
$6,650,000
6Beds
6.1Baths
4,000Sqft
Captiva, Florida, 33924, United States
Welcome to a stunning coastal-modern beachfront estate on Captiva Island’s exclusive Gold Coast. This beautifully enhanced home combines comfort, nature, and luxury across more than 100 feet of pristine Gulf frontage. The property is estate-zoned, allowing the addition of two more structures for those seeking a truly private compound.
Michael Polly
$6,650,000
16500 Captiva Drive
Captiva, Florida, 33924, United States
Welcome to a stunning coastal-modern beachfront estate on Captiva Island’s exclusive Gold Coast. This beautifully enhanced home combines comfort, nature, and luxury across more than 100 feet of pristine Gulf frontage. The property is estate-zoned, allowing the addition of two more structures for those seeking a truly private compound. Recent updates elevate the home’s appeal, including electric roll-down shutters, impact-rated windows and doors, a new pool heater, a large propane tank, and updated landscaping. Inside, you’ll find premium interior finishes throughout, six spacious bedrooms, each with an en-suite bath, along with inviting gathering areas, a media room, and an elevator. Just off the beach path is a convenient outdoor shower and a lower-level bathroom for effortless beach-to-home living. The great room’s floor-to-ceiling sliding glass doors open to sweeping Gulf views, creating an effortless indoor-outdoor flow. The gourmet kitchen features Sub-Zero and Wolf appliances, a coffee bar, and panoramic views that make every meal feel special. Outdoor living shines with an atrium-style, 44-foot heated saltwater pool offering total privacy, a 6 person hotub, plus expansive decks on every level and a rooftop sun deck perfect for sunset views over the Gulf. Additional storage includes a garage plus a large homeowner garage ideal for vehicles and extra space. This property is also a proven high-income rental, generating well over 500K annually, with potential to exceed 600K, backed by a detailed rental history and strong repeat bookings. Whether you’re looking for a refined beachside retreat or a turnkey Income Producing Powerhouse, this Captiva escape offers the best of both.
Read More
Michael Polly
$6,650,000
16500 Captiva Drive
6Beds
6.1Baths
4,000Sqft
$6,650,000
Captiva, Florida, 33924, United States
$6,500,000
Captiva, Florida, 33924, United States
Situated along the most coveted stretch of Captiva Island’s Gold Coast, this 100-foot beachfront lot presents a rare opportunity to start fresh on one of the most iconic shorelines in Southwest Florida.
Michael Polly
$6,500,000
16548 Captiva Drive
Captiva, Florida, 33924, United States
Situated along the most coveted stretch of Captiva Island’s Gold Coast, this 100-foot beachfront lot presents a rare opportunity to start fresh on one of the most iconic shorelines in Southwest Florida. Recently cleared, the property is ready for your vision, whether that means designing a custom beachfront retreat from the ground up or creating something truly extraordinary by combining it with the adjacent 200-foot beachfront parcel and the 100-foot bayfront property across the street. Together, these offerings present the potential for a one-of-a-kind waterfront compound spanning over 5.25 acres with 300 feet on the Gulf of Mexico and 100 feet on the Bay. Cherished as part of a family estate for over 40 years, this location offers dune-wide beachfront, sweeping views, and a level of privacy and serenity that is unmatched. Whether built as a standalone sanctuary or envisioned as part of a grand, multi-property estate, this is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to create your own legacy on Captiva Island.
Read More
Michael Polly
$6,500,000
1.06Sqft
Captiva, Florida, 33924, United States
Situated along the most coveted stretch of Captiva Island’s Gold Coast, this 100-foot beachfront lot presents a rare opportunity to start fresh on one of the most iconic shorelines in Southwest Florida.
Michael Polly
$6,500,000
16548 Captiva Dr
Captiva, Florida, 33924, United States
Situated along the most coveted stretch of Captiva Island’s Gold Coast, this 100-foot beachfront lot presents a rare opportunity to start fresh on one of the most iconic shorelines in Southwest Florida. Recently cleared, the property is ready for your vision, whether that means designing a custom beachfront retreat from the ground up or creating something truly extraordinary by combining it with the adjacent 200-foot beachfront parcel and the 100-foot bayfront property across the street. Together, these offerings present the potential for a one-of-a-kind waterfront compound spanning over 5.25 acres with 300 feet on the Gulf of Mexico and 100 feet on the Bay. Cherished as part of a family estate for over 40 years, this location offers dune-wide beachfront, sweeping views, and a level of privacy and serenity that is unmatched. Whether built as a standalone sanctuary or envisioned as part of a grand, multi-property estate, this is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to create your own legacy on Captiva Island.
Read More
Michael Polly
$6,250,000
3Beds
3.1Baths
2,200Sqft
Captiva, Florida, 33924, United States
Under Construction Direct Beachfront Living in the Heart of Captiva Village Welcome to “Beach Destiny,” an exceptional Gulf-front residence ideally positioned in the heart of Captiva Village, just steps from local dining, boutiques, and entertainment. This rare offering presents the opportunity to own a private beachfront retreat designed to capture the very best of island living.
Michael Polly
$6,250,000
11551 Wightman Lane
Captiva, Florida, 33924, United States
Under Construction Direct Beachfront Living in the Heart of Captiva Village Welcome to “Beach Destiny,” an exceptional Gulf-front residence ideally positioned in the heart of Captiva Village, just steps from local dining, boutiques, and entertainment. This rare offering presents the opportunity to own a private beachfront retreat designed to capture the very best of island living. This spectacular three-story home features five bedrooms, five and one-half baths, and a two-car garage, thoughtfully designed for comfort, entertaining, and panoramic Gulf views. The first level welcomes you with an elegant entry foyer and two well-appointed guest suites with en-suite baths, offering privacy and convenience for visitors. The second level serves as the main living space, highlighted by a spacious family room and a beautifully designed kitchen complete with custom cabinetry, expansive island, granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and a walk-in pantry. Two additional guest suites with private baths are located on this level, along with a generous covered balcony ideal for enjoying coastal breezes and sunset skies. The top floor is dedicated exclusively to the owner’s retreat. This private sanctuary features a sitting area, fireplace, and a luxurious spa-inspired bath with a Jacuzzi tub overlooking the Gulf of America—creating a truly serene escape. With its premier beachfront location, walkability to Captiva Village amenities, and exceptional design, this is a rare opportunity to own a signature Gulf-front residence in one of Southwest Florida’s most coveted destinations. IF you wanted to rent, it would be a highly successful vacation rental, the property could generate approximately 300,000 in annual gross income, making it both an extraordinary lifestyle investment and a compelling income- producing opportunity.
Read More
Michael Polly
$6,250,000
11551 Wightman Lane
3Beds
3.1Baths
2,200Sqft
$6,250,000
Captiva, Florida, 33924, United States
$6,250,000
4Beds
4,578Sqft
Captiva, Florida, 33924, United States
Under Construction Direct Beachfront Living in the Heart of Captiva Village Welcome to “Beach Destiny,” an exceptional Gulf-front residence ideally positioned in the heart of Captiva Village, just steps from local dining, boutiques, and entertainment. This rare offering presents the opportunity to own a private beachfront retreat designed to capture the very best of island living.
Michael Polly
$6,250,000
11551 Wightman Ln
Captiva, Florida, 33924, United States
Under Construction Direct Beachfront Living in the Heart of Captiva Village Welcome to “Beach Destiny,” an exceptional Gulf-front residence ideally positioned in the heart of Captiva Village, just steps from local dining, boutiques, and entertainment. This rare offering presents the opportunity to own a private beachfront retreat designed to capture the very best of island living. This spectacular three-story home features four bedrooms, five full baths, and a two-car garage, thoughtfully designed for comfort, entertaining, and panoramic Gulf views. The first level welcomes you with an elegant entry foyer and two well-appointed guest suites with en-suite baths, offering privacy and convenience for visitors. The second level serves as the main living space, highlighted by a spacious family room and a beautifully designed kitchen complete with custom cabinetry, expansive island, granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and a walk-in pantry. Two additional guest suites with private baths are located on this level, along with a generous covered balcony ideal for enjoying coastal breezes and sunset skies. The top floor is dedicated exclusively to the owner’s retreat. This private sanctuary features a sitting area, fireplace, and a luxurious spa-inspired bath with a Jacuzzi tub overlooking the Gulf of America—creating a truly serene escape. With its premier beachfront location, walkability to Captiva Village amenities, and exceptional design, this is a rare opportunity to own a signature Gulf-front residence in one of Southwest Florida’s most coveted destinations. IF you wanted to rent, it would be a highly successful vacation rental, the property could generate approximately 300,000 in annual gross income, making it both an extraordinary lifestyle investment and a compelling income- producing opportunity.
Read More
Michael Polly
$5,999,000
112.79Sqft
Ocala, Florida, 34482, United States
This magnificent 112 acre private sanctuary farm is nestled perfectly in the NW Ocala horse country. This property offers an opportunity and unique balance of privacy and use. It showcases a serene canvas of carefully mowed pastures, beautiful oak trees, privacy and a very unique opportunity to build your dream home and barn.
Michael Polly
$5,999,000
0 NW 150TH AVENUE
Ocala, Florida, 34482, United States
This magnificent 112 acre private sanctuary farm is nestled perfectly in the NW Ocala horse country. This property offers an opportunity and unique balance of privacy and use. It showcases a serene canvas of carefully mowed pastures, beautiful oak trees, privacy and a very unique opportunity to build your dream home and barn. Strategically located between the World Equestrian Center, HITS and Golden Ocala, makes this site even more prime. New fencing, storage shed, solar panels for well power, and existing water throughs are just some of the features included. Parcel ID for the other two lots: 12253-001-00 12254-000-02
Read More
Michael Polly
$5,490,000
6Beds
4.1Baths
7,306Sqft
Cape Coral, Florida, 33904, United States
Introducing a truly one-of-a-kind waterfront compound where modern luxury living meets unmatched storage, recreation, security, and boating capabilities.
Michael Polly
$5,490,000
1912 SE 33rd Terrace
Cape Coral, Florida, 33904, United States
Introducing a truly one-of-a-kind waterfront compound where modern luxury living meets unmatched storage, recreation, security, and boating capabilities. Rarely does a property offer this level of versatility — featuring a stunning primary residence, a separate showroom-style garage capable of accommodating up to 19 vehicles, an exceptional dock system with four boat lifts rated at approximately 4,500 lb, 16,000 lb, 28,000 lb, and 30,000 lb, and a fully upgraded security system with extensive coverage and dramatic nighttime lighting. The main home showcases contemporary coastal design with an expansive open-concept layout built for both everyday comfort and effortless entertaining. The great room centers around a custom media wall with linear fireplace and flows seamlessly into a chef’s kitchen featuring a massive waterfall island, sleek cabinetry, premium appliances, and designer lighting. The spacious primary suite offers a private retreat with a spa-like bath, while additional bedrooms provide comfortable accommodations for family and guests. A resort-style screened lanai with pool, spa, and covered seating areas completes the home’s indoor-outdoor lifestyle. The detached garage structure is truly extraordinary — a collector’s dream with soaring ceilings, professional-grade lifts, and showroom-quality finishes. Above, a fully finished upper level includes a spacious living area with full kitchen, bar, and two bedrooms, creating ideal guest quarters, extended-family accommodations, or a private retreat separate from the main home. Outside, beautifully landscaped grounds feature expansive paver walkways, maintenance-free turf areas, and multiple waterfront seating spaces. The substantial dock system and covered gathering areas make entertaining effortless, while the advanced security features and strategically designed exterior lighting provide both peace of mind and a stunning presence after dark. This is more than a home — it is a private waterfront estate designed for those who want it all: luxury living, serious garage space, premier boating facilities, enhanced security, and a lifestyle few properties can offer.
Read More
Michael Polly
$5,490,000
1912 SE 33rd Terrace
6Beds
4.1Baths
7,306Sqft
$5,490,000
Cape Coral, Florida, 33904, United States
$5,300,000
4Beds
4.1Baths
4,000Sqft
6230 Estero Boulevard #401, Fort Myers Beach, Florida, 33931, United States
Step into a world where unparalleled luxury meets the tranquil shores of Estero Island. Here, we present Gulfside Twelve, an exclusive collection of residences that redefine beachfront living. Your 4,700 SF sanctuary, offers a unique blend of sophisticated elegance & serene coastal vistas. Designed for those who seek an intimate connection w/ the sea.
Michael Polly
$5,300,000
6230 Estero Boulevard #401
6230 Estero Boulevard #401, Fort Myers Beach, Florida, 33931, United States
Step into a world where unparalleled luxury meets the tranquil shores of Estero Island. Here, we present Gulfside Twelve, an exclusive collection of residences that redefine beachfront living. Your 4,700 SF sanctuary, offers a unique blend of sophisticated elegance & serene coastal vistas. Designed for those who seek an intimate connection w/ the sea. Collaborate with a dedicated interior designer to personalize your space, ensuring it reflects your unique style. Expansive outdoor living areas extend the luxury of the indoors to the soothing 180 of beachfront, creating a harmonious blend of comfort & natural beauty w/ amenities that encapsulate the essence of a luxury resort: a magnificent pool, spa, & sun deck, all framed by private cabanas. Step right out onto some of the finest sand & widest beach on the island. A coveted location on the serene south end, you are mere moments to an array of island cuisine, grocery, boutique shops & a choice of marinas to dock your boat & explore the open waters of the Gulf Coast while Lovers Key State Park offers endless natural exploration & tranquility. Property ID to be determined.
Read More
Michael Polly
$5,300,000
6230 Estero Boulevard #401
4Beds
4.1Baths
4,000Sqft
$5,300,000
6230 Estero Boulevard #401, Fort Myers Beach, Florida, 33931, United States
$5,250,000
4Beds
0.1Baths
4,735Sqft
Fort Myers, Florida, 33919, United States
Experience luxury living in the prestigious Town and River community, renowned for its multimillion-dollar homes and exceptional deep-water boating access. This new construction home, scheduled for completion in 2025, represents the pinnacle of modern craftsmanship and design. Built to the highest construction standards and codes, this solid concrete home promises durability and elegance.
Michael Polly
$5,250,000
846 Cypress Lake Cir
Fort Myers, Florida, 33919, United States
Experience luxury living in the prestigious Town and River community, renowned for its multimillion-dollar homes and exceptional deep-water boating access. This new construction home, scheduled for completion in 2025, represents the pinnacle of modern craftsmanship and design. Built to the highest construction standards and codes, this solid concrete home promises durability and elegance. Boasting a prime location in one of Fort Myers most desirable boating communities, w/ no HOA, this property is a boaters dream. The property offers intersecting canal views w/ quick direct access to the Gulf & Bay waters, right off the River. The home will feature a brand new seawall & a spacious 3-car garage. The opportunity to customize this home is still available, allowing you to add your personal touch! Constructed by one of the areas premier custom home builders, every detail will be crafted w/ precision and care. Situated close to Sanibel & Captiva Islands, schools, hospitals, shopping, dining, etc. this home is not just a residence but a lifestyle choice. Embrace the blend of tranquility & convenience in this exceptional new construction home, where every day feels like a vacation!
Read More
Michael Polly
$5,250,000
846 Cypress Lake Cir
4Beds
0.1Baths
4,735Sqft
$5,250,000
Fort Myers, Florida, 33919, United States
$5,250,000
4Beds
4.1Baths
4,735Sqft
Fort Myers, Florida, 33919, United States
Experience luxury living in the prestigious Town and River community, renowned for its multimillion-dollar homes and exceptional deep-water boating access. This new construction home, scheduled for completion in 2025, represents the pinnacle of modern craftsmanship and design. Built to the highest construction standards and codes, this solid concrete home promises durability and elegance.
Michael Polly
$5,250,000
846 Cypress Lake Circle
Fort Myers, Florida, 33919, United States
Experience luxury living in the prestigious Town and River community, renowned for its multimillion-dollar homes and exceptional deep-water boating access. This new construction home, scheduled for completion in 2025, represents the pinnacle of modern craftsmanship and design. Built to the highest construction standards and codes, this solid concrete home promises durability and elegance. Boasting a prime location in one of Fort Myers most desirable boating communities, w/ no HOA, this property is a boaters dream. The property offers intersecting canal views w/ quick direct access to the Gulf & Bay waters, right off the River. The home will feature a brand new seawall & a spacious 3-car garage. The opportunity to customize this home is still available, allowing you to add your personal touch! Constructed by one of the areas premier custom home builders, every detail will be crafted w/ precision and care. Situated close to Sanibel & Captiva Islands, schools, hospitals, shopping, dining, etc. this home is not just a residence but a lifestyle choice. Embrace the blend of tranquility & convenience in this exceptional new construction home, where every day feels like a vacation!
Read More
Michael Polly
$5,250,000
846 Cypress Lake Circle
4Beds
4.1Baths
4,735Sqft
$5,250,000
Fort Myers, Florida, 33919, United States
$5,250,000
4Beds
3Baths
2,897Sqft
Captiva, Florida, 33924, United States
Nestled between the Gulf and Bay, this stunning beachfront home offers unparalleled 180-degree views of both pristine waters, coupled with direct deep-water boating access and a private dock space with lift. Perfect for those who enjoy both the beach and boating lifestyle, this residence seamlessly blends luxurious indoor spaces with expansive outdoor living areas.
Michael Polly
$5,250,000
15899 Captiva Drive
Captiva, Florida, 33924, United States
Nestled between the Gulf and Bay, this stunning beachfront home offers unparalleled 180-degree views of both pristine waters, coupled with direct deep-water boating access and a private dock space with lift. Perfect for those who enjoy both the beach and boating lifestyle, this residence seamlessly blends luxurious indoor spaces with expansive outdoor living areas. The thoughtfully designed split floor plan provides ultimate privacy for owners and guests, while the open-concept gathering areas flow effortlessly from room to room. Sunlight pours through large windows, highlighting the voluminous interiors and enhancing the beauty of the home. The light-filled spaces lead to multiple outdoor areas ideal for entertaining or relaxing, all while taking in the spectacular views. Enjoy easy maintenance witha galvalume roof, composite decking, aluminum railings, durable stucco finish, impact windows and doors and more. The beautifully landscaped property boasts a large fenced backyard with pavers, perfect for hosting or enjoying the outdoors, plus a spacious pool and spa for ultimate relaxation. The gourmet kitchen offers fantastic views of the Gulf, stone countertops, a large pantry, a cozy dining area, and an adjacent deck for alfresco dining. The master suite is a true retreat, featuring incredible Gulf views, a spacious bath, two walk-in closets, and a private office. With a 3-car garage, this home is as practical as it is luxurious—making it the perfect waterfront getaway. NOTE, this property is atsome of the highest elevation in the X Zone of Captiva Island.
Read More
Michael Polly
$5,250,000
15899 Captiva Drive
4Beds
3Baths
2,897Sqft
$5,250,000
Captiva, Florida, 33924, United States
$5,250,000
4Beds
5,354Sqft
Captiva, Florida, 33924, United States
Nestled between the Gulf and Bay, this stunning beachfront home offers unparalleled 180-degree views of both pristine waters, coupled with direct deep-water boating access and a private dock space with lift. Perfect for those who enjoy both the beach and boating lifestyle, this residence seamlessly blends luxurious indoor spaces with expansive outdoor living areas.
Michael Polly
$5,250,000
15899 Captiva Dr
Captiva, Florida, 33924, United States
Nestled between the Gulf and Bay, this stunning beachfront home offers unparalleled 180-degree views of both pristine waters, coupled with direct deep-water boating access and a private dock space with lift. Perfect for those who enjoy both the beach and boating lifestyle, this residence seamlessly blends luxurious indoor spaces with expansive outdoor living areas. The thoughtfully designed split floor plan provides ultimate privacy for owners and guests, while the open-concept gathering areas flow effortlessly from room to room. Sunlight pours through large windows, highlighting the voluminous interiors and enhancing the beauty of the home. The light-filled spaces lead to multiple outdoor areas ideal for entertaining or relaxing, all while taking in the spectacular views. Enjoy easy maintenance with a galvalume roof, composite decking, aluminum railings, durable stucco finish, impact windows and doors and more. The beautifully landscaped property boasts a large fenced backyard with pavers, perfect for hosting or enjoying the outdoors, plus a spacious pool and spa for ultimate relaxation. The gourmet kitchen offers fantastic views of the Gulf, stone countertops, a large pantry, a cozy dining area, and an adjacent deck for alfresco dining. The master suite is a true retreat, featuring incredible Gulf views, a spacious bath, two walk-in closets, and a private office. With a 3-car garage, this home is as practical as it is luxurious—making it the perfect waterfront getaway. NOTE, this property is at some of the highest elevation in the X Zone of Captiva Island,
Read More
Michael Polly
Favorite this home
Enter your email to continue
or
By signing in you agree to UniqueHomes Terms of Use and Privacy Policy