Michael Polly
Royal Shell Real Estate
- Address : 959 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel Island,United States
About
Michael has earned the ePRO, Graduate Real Estate Institute (GRI) and is a licensed USCG Captain. Michael became the first Realtor in SW Florida and the 11th in the state to earn his Accredited Seller Representative (ASR). This designation is awarded based on both actual performance and required education. The first awarded in SW Florida. Michael has completed the education and training necessary to earn his Certified Property Valuator (CPV), only the second awarded in Lee County. He offers Broker Price Opinions as part of his advanced service to his clients. Most recently Michael has completed advanced training and work review and is now certified by National Valuations Standards Institute. Michael has also earned his (CDPE) Certified Distressed Property Expert to assist buyers and sellers with bank owned foreclosures and short sale properties. Michael worked for 15 years with UPS in a variety of roles. His training and management of projects helped him build his own business.
Contact
$799,000
4Beds
0.1Baths
4,214Sqft
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
Inviting Olde Florida style pool home, centrally located in the desirable Belle Meade subdivision. This 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath home offers a bright, open layout with abundant natural light, a spacious double garage, and a large open pool. Brick pavers enhance both the front entry and rear patio for timeless curb appeal.
Michael Polly
$799,000
9225 Dimmick Dr
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
Inviting Olde Florida style pool home, centrally located in the desirable Belle Meade subdivision. This 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath home offers a bright, open layout with abundant natural light, a spacious double garage, and a large open pool. Brick pavers enhance both the front entry and rear patio for timeless curb appeal. The kitchen features a butcher block island, breakfast bar, and gas range, flowing seamlessly into the dining area, living room, and additional front room. The grande primary suite with vaulted ceiling includes two walk in closets and an ensuite with a large walk in shower. Three additional guest bedrooms offer excellent flexibility, along with generous storage throughout. A powder room is conveniently located on the main level. The backyard is designed for entertaining, complete with a vinyl privacy fence, expansive patio, and a new outdoor kitchen. Major improvements completed • Roof • Luxury plank flooring throughout • Updated bathroom vanities • Two zone HVAC • New pool equipment • Resurfaced pool • Gutters • Hurricane rated front door, sliders, and garage doors • Front porch Composite deck and stairs • Interior Paint throughout Located near The Sanibel School, the Rec Center, and Ding Darling Wildlife Sanctuary, this home blends convenience, charm, and everyday comfort. A fantastic opportunity not to be missed.
Read More
Michael Polly
$799,000
3Beds
2.1Baths
2,471Sqft
Bonita Springs, Florida, 34134, United States
Lovely lakefront pool home in the highly desirable community of Capri at Pelican Landing. This light and bright 3-bedroom, 2 and a 1/2 bath residence with a den features numerous updates, including a beautifully remodeled kitchen and primary bath with stunning quartz countertops. The spacious great room offers volume ceilings and serene views, while the newer 2023 roof adds peace of mind.
Michael Polly
$799,000
24784 Hollybrier Lane
Bonita Springs, Florida, 34134, United States
Lovely lakefront pool home in the highly desirable community of Capri at Pelican Landing. This light and bright 3-bedroom, 2 and a 1/2 bath residence with a den features numerous updates, including a beautifully remodeled kitchen and primary bath with stunning quartz countertops. The spacious great room offers volume ceilings and serene views, while the newer 2023 roof adds peace of mind. New carpet and exterior paint in 2023. The hot water heater was replaced in 2022. Step outside to your private lanai and pool, the perfect place to unwind and enjoy breathtaking sunsets over the lake. Located on 2,400 acres west of US-41 and nestled along Estero Bay, Pelican Landing is the only community in the area with its own private beach island, accessible by a community shuttle ferry. This amenity-rich community offers optional golf memberships, boating, tennis, pickleball, bocce, kayaking, and a fully equipped fitness center along with the exclusive beach island and ferry service that runs every 30 minutes during season. This exceptional home combines luxurious updates, resort-style amenities, and an unbeatable location lending your ideal Florida retreat.
Read More
Michael Polly
$799,000
24784 Hollybrier Lane
3Beds
2.1Baths
2,471Sqft
$799,000
Bonita Springs, Florida, 34134, United States
$799,000
2Beds
0.1Baths
3,584Sqft
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
Discover the charm of island living in this light-filled coastal cottage, with a distinct treehouse ambiance. Thoughtfully designed with custom cabinetry in every room, this residence blends craftsmanship with relaxed tropical living. Featuring 2 bedrooms and 2.5 baths, each space opens to its own screened porch, inviting gentle breezes and seamless indoor–outdoor living.
Michael Polly
$799,000
662 Donax St
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
Discover the charm of island living in this light-filled coastal cottage, with a distinct treehouse ambiance. Thoughtfully designed with custom cabinetry in every room, this residence blends craftsmanship with relaxed tropical living. Featuring 2 bedrooms and 2.5 baths, each space opens to its own screened porch, inviting gentle breezes and seamless indoor–outdoor living. The remodeled kitchen (2017) boasts quartz countertops, new cabinetry, and a bright, airy atmosphere ideal for casual coastal dining. Bedrooms feature hardwood floors and plantation shutters, enhancing the home’s warm, island-inspired character. A unique atrium-style entrance anchors the split floor plan, creating exceptional privacy by separating public and private living areas with a lush, light-filled foyer. Ample storage includes two generous closets on the main level, with even more potential below. Located just a short stroll from the Donax Beach access, this ideally situated property offers effortless proximity to restaurants, shelling, biking, boating, and quick on- and off-island travel. Artful, tropical, and truly one-of-a-kind, this enchanting retreat is perfectly suited as a full-time residence or an exceptional investment property.
Read More
Michael Polly
$799,000
3Beds
2Baths
1,810Sqft
Fort Myers Beach, Florida, 33931, United States
4141 Bay Beach Lane #426 A Unique Opportunity! Discover this rare second floor Turnkey, End Unit at Waterside at Bay Beach located at the desirable south end of Ft. Myers Beach with exquisite views of the Intracoastal waterway with passing boats and occasional dolphins and manatees.
Michael Polly
$799,000
4141 Bay Beach Lane #426
Fort Myers Beach, Florida, 33931, United States
4141 Bay Beach Lane #426 A Unique Opportunity! Discover this rare second floor Turnkey, End Unit at Waterside at Bay Beach located at the desirable south end of Ft. Myers Beach with exquisite views of the Intracoastal waterway with passing boats and occasional dolphins and manatees. Why is the second floor at Waterside 4 so unique? This unique second floor end-unit not only has exceptional, close to nature, views of the Intracoastal waterway from every room in the unit but it has two oversized private walkout decks one approximately 40x40 ft. in addition to the large lanai. This integrates the indoor and outdoor space to allow for extended activities and entertainment by all ages. Patio tables , chairs and lounge chairs with cushions are included. As an end unit ,natural light streams through the additional side windows offering stunning views of the water and the fishing pier. All three bedrooms have 8ft sliding glass doors and provide access to the outdoor decks. The master bedroom has a larger sliding door with 3 panels of glass and a walk-in closet and ensuite bath with separate bath and shower. All 3 bedrooms have wall mounted TV’s. This unique second floor unit also features 11ft ceilings found only here and in the penthouses ,creating an exceptional sense of space. As a result it also allows for extended cabinetry for extra storage and extended height in the screened-in lanai which can be completely enclosed with the electric hurricane shutters. Yes there is more on the second floor. Located down the hall are two guest suites, well equipped gym, social room with adjoining kitchen, sauna and showers thereby providing unmatched convenience for hosting. Easily accessible down one floor are the outside amenities which include a waterfront pool, spa, BBQ’s, tennis courts and a fishing pier. Within the Bay Beach community is a Nature Preserve with walking trails, putting green, bocce and pickle ball courts. Private deeded beach access is available as a member of this community. Fort Myers is famous for its sugar sand beaches and most spectacular sunsets. Lovers Key State Park is also close by as is the Santini Plaza. Paradise is waiting .
Read More
Michael Polly
$799,000
4141 Bay Beach Lane #426
3Beds
2Baths
1,810Sqft
$799,000
Fort Myers Beach, Florida, 33931, United States
$799,000
3Beds
2Baths
1,608Sqft
Fort Myers, Florida, 33901, United States
Historic Seminole Park gem in the heart of Fort Myers, just minutes to downtown, the River District, golf courses, dining, and entertainment. Celebrating its centennial in 2025, this landmark property spans an entire block and blends preserved historic character with thoughtful modern updates.
Michael Polly
$799,000
3650 McKinley Avenue
Fort Myers, Florida, 33901, United States
Historic Seminole Park gem in the heart of Fort Myers, just minutes to downtown, the River District, golf courses, dining, and entertainment. Celebrating its centennial in 2025, this landmark property spans an entire block and blends preserved historic character with thoughtful modern updates. The original Model-T garage has been fully converted into a functional steam room and laundry room, offering a rare amenity. Expansive outdoor living includes a large grilling area, private irrigation well, and mature landscaping. The home is perfectly oriented to enjoy both sunrise and sunset. Major updates include a metal roof (2018), updated HVAC and ductwork (2013–2014), and PVC plumbing (2017). The kitchen features preserved 1925 upper cabinets paired with custom lower cabinetry and KitchenAid appliances. Bathrooms showcase pedestal sinks, a replica clawfoot tub, and restored subway and penny tile: matte-finished wood floors and energy-efficient LED lighting run throughout. Additional highlights include plantation shutters, glass awnings, and original single-hung sash windows. The versatile floor plan offers three bedrooms, two bathrooms, a library, a den, formal living room, and family room. A rare opportunity to own a historic Fort Myers home near downtown and golf, thoughtfully updated for modern living while preserving its timeless Seminole Park charm.
Read More
Michael Polly
$799,000
3650 McKinley Avenue
3Beds
2Baths
1,608Sqft
$799,000
Fort Myers, Florida, 33901, United States
$795,900
2Beds
2Baths
1,042Sqft
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
THE PERFECT SUNDIAL LOCATION. The J building has long been established as one of the most desireable locations in Sundial West providing direct gulf views and easy access to the adjacent Sundial amenities area. A great personal or investment property. In J304, you will have stunning gulf views from all living areas, the lanai and the primary bedroom which also has private access to the lanai.
Michael Polly
$795,900
1501 Middle Gulf Drive #304J
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
THE PERFECT SUNDIAL LOCATION. The J building has long been established as one of the most desireable locations in Sundial West providing direct gulf views and easy access to the adjacent Sundial amenities area. A great personal or investment property. In J304, you will have stunning gulf views from all living areas, the lanai and the primary bedroom which also has private access to the lanai. The condo has a completely new interior including stunning slate counter tops, shaker style cabinets, stone type floor tile, carpeting in the bedrooms, new bathrooms, new kitchen, wind rated windows and doors-the list goes on. There also is a seperate large outside storage closet. This condo shines with brightness and newness. Adjacent to the J Building are the many amenities offered by Sundial. There are resort restaurants, the resort pool and bar, cabanas, fitness center, miles of beach to explore, kayak and bike rentals and a gracious center to welcome guests and owners.
Read More
Michael Polly
$795,900
1501 Middle Gulf Drive #304J
2Beds
2Baths
1,042Sqft
$795,900
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
$795,900
2Beds
1,042Sqft
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
THE PERFECT SUNDIAL LOCATION. The J building has long been established as one of the most desireable locations in Sundial West providing direct gulf views and easy access to the adjacent Sundial amenities area.Ideal for personal use or an investment. In J304, you will have stunning gulf views from all living areas, the lanai and the primary bedroom which also has private access to the lanai.
Michael Polly
$795,900
1501 Middle Gulf Dr #304J
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
THE PERFECT SUNDIAL LOCATION. The J building has long been established as one of the most desireable locations in Sundial West providing direct gulf views and easy access to the adjacent Sundial amenities area.Ideal for personal use or an investment. In J304, you will have stunning gulf views from all living areas, the lanai and the primary bedroom which also has private access to the lanai. The condo has a completely new interior including stunning slate counter tops, shaker style cabinets, stone type floor tile, carpeting in the bedrooms, new bathrooms, new kitchen, wind rated windows and doors-the list goes on. There also is a seperate large outside storage closet. This condo shines with brightness and newness. Adjacent to the J Building are the many amenities offered by Sundial. There are resort restaurants, the resort pool and bar, cabanas, fitness center, miles of beach to explore, kayak and bike rentals and a gracious center to welcome guests and owners.
Read More
Michael Polly
$795,000
3Beds
2Baths
1,639Sqft
Fort Myers Beach, Florida, 33931, United States
Enjoy serene bay and lake views from this spacious corner residence at Waterside. This second-level 3-bedroom, 2-bath home features 11-foot ceilings and an extended terrace for outdoor living, perfect for sunsets and watching the activity on Estero Bay.
Michael Polly
$795,000
4198 Bay Beach Lane #113
Fort Myers Beach, Florida, 33931, United States
Enjoy serene bay and lake views from this spacious corner residence at Waterside. This second-level 3-bedroom, 2-bath home features 11-foot ceilings and an extended terrace for outdoor living, perfect for sunsets and watching the activity on Estero Bay. This condo is on the same level as the social room, gym and guest suites so a lot of your amenities are just steps away! The residence offers travertine flooring, upgraded carpet, granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, California closets, hurricane shutters, under-building parking, and extra storage. Offered furnished with some exclusions. Waterside residents enjoy resort-style amenities including a pool and spa, fitness center, sauna, steam room, tennis courts, social room, guest suites, walking/jogging path, fishing pier, and private beach access. Ideally located on the quiet south end of Fort Myers Beach with convenient access to restaurants, shopping, and Lover’s Key State Park. Boat docks available for lease or purchase!
Read More
Michael Polly
$795,000
4198 Bay Beach Lane #113
3Beds
2Baths
1,639Sqft
$795,000
Fort Myers Beach, Florida, 33931, United States
$787,000
3Beds
2Baths
1,893Sqft
Fort Myers, Florida, 33908, United States
Stunning Sunsets are “included” with this lakefront masterpiece home! Feel the “wow factor” as you step inside this 3 bedroom den pool home that’s nestled on over 1 acre in the heart of South Fort Myers. Perfectly positioned along an expansive lake with breathtaking views, this home is designed for the most discerning buyer.
Michael Polly
$787,000
7337 Lake Drive
Fort Myers, Florida, 33908, United States
Stunning Sunsets are “included” with this lakefront masterpiece home! Feel the “wow factor” as you step inside this 3 bedroom den pool home that’s nestled on over 1 acre in the heart of South Fort Myers. Perfectly positioned along an expansive lake with breathtaking views, this home is designed for the most discerning buyer. The owners spared no expense - showcasing 400,000 to renovate the home from the studs out with impeccable craftsmanship and high-end finishes throughout. The open, light-filled floor plan with lake views from every room creates a seamless blend of comfort and sophistication, enhanced by neutral designer paint tones and tile flooring that flows throughout the entire home. The kitchen is a true centerpiece with a full-slab quartz waterfall island with generous seating —perfect for gathering and entertaining. Features include a designer backsplash, farmhouse sink, brand-new appliances, wine cooler, pantry, soft-close cabinetry, crown molding, and LED lighting under the cabinets. The thoughtfully designed split-bedroom layout ensures privacy, with each bedroom offering tranquil lake views. The expansive primary suite measures over 16x16 and provides a true retreat. The spa-inspired en-suite bath features quartz countertops and a luxurious rainfall shower. A spacious custom walk-in closet completes the suite. Step outside to your own tropical paradise set on over an acre of beautifully reimagined grounds. The redesigned enclosed lanai has been upgraded for elevated outdoor living, offering two separate sitting areas ideal for entertaining. The fully renovated pool boasts new tiles, pavers and coping, resurfaced interior, LED color-changing lighting, super screen fabric, and a picture screen cage. Three sets of Impact glass sliders add protection and peace of mind. The lush, mature landscaping is extraordinary, featuring a variety of palms and flowering trees along with multiple tree swings. A fenced area provides a safe play space for pets, while a large, tiled pad tucked beneath the trees creates a serene Zen-inspired sanctuary. The brand-new composite dock is the perfect place to watch the sunset, launch a kayak, or cast a line. Additional upgrades include a 2024 roof, A/C, new water heater, new pool heater 2026, plus all-new re-piped plumbing and updated electrical, foam insulation, and whole-yard irrigation. Truly move-in ready, there is absolutely nothing to do but move in and enjoy. Located in the highly desirable Heritage Farms Lake Addition in South Fort Myers, just minutes from Lakes Park, this property delivers the perfect balance of seclusion and convenience. And, theres plenty of extra space to park your RV, Boat, or toys! Plus, no HOA fees! Close to shopping, restaurants, white sand beaches and Southwest Florida International Airport, this extraordinary property delivers luxury, location, land, waterfront, and lifestyle—an exceptionally rare combination in the heart of South Fort Myers. You are now HOME!
Read More
Michael Polly
$785,000
3Beds
2.2Baths
2,221Sqft
Bonita Springs, Florida, 34135, United States
Welcome to this beautifully maintained Shelby floor plan in the Seasons at Bonita. Perfectly positioned on an oversized lot with peaceful long lake views, this move-in-ready home offers three bedrooms plus a den, two full baths, and two half baths, including a convenient pool bath.
Michael Polly
$785,000
28001 Longboat Key Run
Bonita Springs, Florida, 34135, United States
Welcome to this beautifully maintained Shelby floor plan in the Seasons at Bonita. Perfectly positioned on an oversized lot with peaceful long lake views, this move-in-ready home offers three bedrooms plus a den, two full baths, and two half baths, including a convenient pool bath. The open-concept kitchen is both stylish and functional, featuring 42 white cabinetry, quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, a tile backsplash, and upgraded lighting. Thoughtful details throughout the home include plantation shutters, tray ceilings, crown molding, and a custom California Closets. The primary suite offers dual sinks, a soaking tub, and an oversized walk-in closet. The extra-deep 2 car tandem garage provides excellent storage space, while the screened lanai invites you to relax and entertain with an outdoor kitchen and serene lake views. Recent updates include a great room feature wall with dry bar, new pool heater, refrigerator, updated lighting and ceiling fans, and new lanai screens. Seasons at Bonita is a gated, resort-style community offering a spectacular clubhouse, beach-entry pool, lap lanes, tiki hut, fitness center, tennis, pickleball, bocce, social room, and dog park. Ideally located near beaches, dining, shopping, and the airport, this home offers the perfect blend of comfort, style, and Southwest Florida living. This is a rare opportunity to own a beautifully appointed home on a premium lot in an exceptional location.
Read More
Michael Polly
$785,000
28001 Longboat Key Run
3Beds
2.2Baths
2,221Sqft
$785,000
Bonita Springs, Florida, 34135, United States
$779,900
3Beds
2.1Baths
2,466Sqft
Fort Myers, Florida, 33913, United States
Welcome to Azzurra at Pelican Preserve, where every day feels like a getaway. This beautifully maintained 3-bedroom plus den home offers elegance, comfort, and the best of resort-style living — all set against the lush backdrop of the golf course.
Michael Polly
$779,900
10507 Azzurra Drive
Fort Myers, Florida, 33913, United States
Welcome to Azzurra at Pelican Preserve, where every day feels like a getaway. This beautifully maintained 3-bedroom plus den home offers elegance, comfort, and the best of resort-style living — all set against the lush backdrop of the golf course. Step inside to find soaring 12-foot tray ceilings, plantation shutters, and a stunning kitchen featuring granite countertops, upgraded appliances, and custom backsplash details. The spacious layout flows seamlessly to a private pool and spa, perfect for quiet mornings or sunset swims. With a convenient lanai half-bath and storm-smart protection, this home was built for both beauty and peace of mind. But what truly sets this property apart is the community. At Pelican Preserve, life is vibrant, social, and full of opportunity. Whether you’re looking for relaxation, recreation, or connection — you’ll find it here. Enjoy three sparkling pools (including one indoors), a state-of-the-art fitness center and spa, and a 27-hole championship golf course. Spend the afternoon playing pickleball or tennis, or explore the nature preserve, boardwalks, and fishing pier. Take part in arts and crafts, woodworking, billiards, or join one of the many social and musical groups. And when it’s time to unwind, enjoy a meal at one of the community’s two restaurants or catch a show at the on-site theater. Located just minutes from shopping, dining, I-75, Southwest Florida International Airport, and the spring training parks of the Red Sox and Twins, this is truly the perfect place to live, play, and thrive. At Pelican Preserve, it’s not just about finding a home — it’s about finding your community. Come see why this award-winning 55 neighborhood continues to be one of Florida’s most celebrated destinations for active adult living.
Read More
Michael Polly
$779,900
10507 Azzurra Drive
3Beds
2.1Baths
2,466Sqft
$779,900
Fort Myers, Florida, 33913, United States
$779,000
2Beds
2Baths
2,039Sqft
Fort Myers, Florida, 33908, United States
Stunning, impressive, and beautiful are the words youll use to describe this coach home nestled on the 13th hole in Gulf Harbour Yacht & Country Club. With over 2,000 s/f of living space, this TURNKEY 2 bedroom Den first floor home creates a feel of grandeur the moment you enter. The entryway hall alcoves set the tone with significant art treatments with interesting stories.
Michael Polly
$779,000
11239 Bienvenida Court #102
Fort Myers, Florida, 33908, United States
Stunning, impressive, and beautiful are the words youll use to describe this coach home nestled on the 13th hole in Gulf Harbour Yacht & Country Club. With over 2,000 s/f of living space, this TURNKEY 2 bedroom Den first floor home creates a feel of grandeur the moment you enter. The entryway hall alcoves set the tone with significant art treatments with interesting stories. Tile floors flow throughout the main living area, and hand scraped wood floors encompass the bedrooms and den. Volume ceilings with crown molding create plenty of space and light, while designer touches and owner upgrades are abound. The kitchen offers granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, a natural-gas cooktop, plus ample areas to gather the family for gourmet meals. The primary suite is split from the guest bedroom for privacy and has two large closets-one walk-in with designer shelving. The ensuite bath is spacious with separate shower and jetted soaking tub, plus double vanity and vessel sinks. The outside patio has been converted into an under air usable space to include tile floors plus sliding sun shades and even electrical hurricane shutters for protection. Long range waterfront views never looked so good! Two car garage with epoxy floor coating a plus! AC is 11 years old with a 1-year remaining warranty. The community of Coronado offers a community pool. Additionally, stellar amenities are all optional at Gulf Harbour Yacht & Country Club. Golf and Sports Memberships include an array of activities such as golf, tennis, a state-of-the-art fitness center, full service spa, several restaurants, private beach, and a deep-water marina. You are now HOME! Agents-please see confidential comments.
Read More
Michael Polly
$779,000
11239 Bienvenida Court #102
2Beds
2Baths
2,039Sqft
$779,000
Fort Myers, Florida, 33908, United States
Favorite this home
Enter your email to continue
or
By signing in you agree to UniqueHomes Terms of Use and Privacy Policy