Michael Polly
Royal Shell Real Estate
- Address : 959 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel Island,United States
About
Michael has earned the ePRO, Graduate Real Estate Institute (GRI) and is a licensed USCG Captain. Michael became the first Realtor in SW Florida and the 11th in the state to earn his Accredited Seller Representative (ASR). This designation is awarded based on both actual performance and required education. The first awarded in SW Florida. Michael has completed the education and training necessary to earn his Certified Property Valuator (CPV), only the second awarded in Lee County. He offers Broker Price Opinions as part of his advanced service to his clients. Most recently Michael has completed advanced training and work review and is now certified by National Valuations Standards Institute. Michael has also earned his (CDPE) Certified Distressed Property Expert to assist buyers and sellers with bank owned foreclosures and short sale properties. Michael worked for 15 years with UPS in a variety of roles. His training and management of projects helped him build his own business.
Contact
$2,195,000
4Beds
0.1Baths
6,638Sqft
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
Experience the ultimate blend of luxury and coastal charm in the exclusive gated community known as Kinzie Island, an island within an island on Sanibel Island, where unmatched amenities and a welcoming atmosphere create the perfect island retreat. This highly elevated 4-bedroom, 3.
Michael Polly
$2,195,000
519 Kinzie Island Ct
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
Experience the ultimate blend of luxury and coastal charm in the exclusive gated community known as Kinzie Island, an island within an island on Sanibel Island, where unmatched amenities and a welcoming atmosphere create the perfect island retreat. This highly elevated 4-bedroom, 3.5-bath home is located on Sanibels convenient east end just steps to white sand beaches and a short bike ride to the Historical Sanibel Lighthouse. This light-filled retreat boasts soaring ceilings, impact windows and doors, newer roof and an open-concept design that maximizes space and natural light. As you enter the home you are suddenly moved by a a beautiful foyer and the huge greatroom area. The chef’s kitchen is a show stopper with double islands featuring leather granite and quartz counter tops, a gas range, a farmhouse sink, and a walk-in pantry.— The spacious VIP suite is a sanctuary with a beautiful bath, double vanities, a soaking tub, and a extra large walk-in closet. The separete guest suites are generous and private. The quality to detail, real oak flooring, decorative tile floors, incrediable lighting, beautiful fixtures, are all amazing. Outside you will relax and enjoy a beautiful private pool area, incredaiable out door deck space a, and more. The home also features a 3-car garage and abundant storage. Kinzie Island is like no other! The Community amenities are unparalleled, featuring private boat dockage, deeded beach access, Beachside private facilities and storage lockers, a fitness room, Community pool with facilities, pickleball and tennis courts, bocce, shuffleboard, and a dog park. This is a fantastic lifestyle enjoyed by only 22 private residences. Kinzie Island, an island within an island on Sanibel Island.
Read More
Michael Polly
$2,195,000
519 Kinzie Island Ct
4Beds
0.1Baths
6,638Sqft
$2,195,000
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
$2,195,000
4Beds
3.1Baths
3,018Sqft
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
Experience the ultimate blend of luxury and coastal charm in the exclusive gated community known as Kinzie Island, an island within an island on Sanibel Island, where unmatched amenities and a welcoming atmosphere create the perfect island retreat. This highly elevated 4-bedroom, 3.
Michael Polly
$2,195,000
519 Kinzie Island Court
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
Experience the ultimate blend of luxury and coastal charm in the exclusive gated community known as Kinzie Island, an island within an island on Sanibel Island, where unmatched amenities and a welcoming atmosphere create the perfect island retreat. This highly elevated 4-bedroom, 3.5-bath home is located on Sanibels convenient east end just steps to white sand beaches and a short bike ride to the Historical Sanibel Lighthouse. This light-filled retreat boasts soaring ceilings, impact windows and doors, newer roof and an open-concept design that maximizes space and natural light. As you enter the home you are suddenly moved by a a beautiful foyer and the huge greatroom area. The chef’s kitchen is a show stopper with double islands featuring leather granite and quartz counter tops, a gas range, a farmhouse sink, and a walk-in pantry.— The spacious VIP suite is a sanctuary with a beautiful bath, double vanities, a soaking tub, and a extra large walk-in closet. The separete guest suites are generous and private. The quality to detail, real oak flooring, decorative tile floors, incrediable lighting, beautiful fixtures, are all amazing. Outside you will relax and enjoy a beautiful private pool area, incredaiable out door deck space a, and more. The home also features a 3-car garage and abundant storage. Kinzie Island is like no other! The Community amenities are unparalleled, featuring private boat dockage, deeded beach access, Beachside private facilities and storage lockers, a fitness room, Community pool with facilities, pickleball and tennis courts, bocce, shuffleboard, and a dog park. This is a fantastic lifestyle enjoyed by only 22 private residences. Kinzie Island, an island within an island on Sanibel Island.
Read More
Michael Polly
$2,195,000
519 Kinzie Island Court
4Beds
3.1Baths
3,018Sqft
$2,195,000
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
$2,100,000
20.19Sqft
Ocala, Florida, 34482, United States
A great multi-use land opportunity on Millionaires Row. Just 5 miles from the World Equestrian Center, 4.5 Miles to Golden Ocala and 2.4 miles to I-75. Zoned for Residential, Agricultural, and Commercial use, this unique property presents numerous opportunities. This parcel occupies two corners of the four-way stop at HWY 326 and HWY 225A.
Michael Polly
$2,100,000
13009-001-22 HWY 326 AND 225A
Ocala, Florida, 34482, United States
A great multi-use land opportunity on Millionaires Row. Just 5 miles from the World Equestrian Center, 4.5 Miles to Golden Ocala and 2.4 miles to I-75. Zoned for Residential, Agricultural, and Commercial use, this unique property presents numerous opportunities. This parcel occupies two corners of the four-way stop at HWY 326 and HWY 225A.
Read More
Michael Polly
$2,099,999
5Beds
5Baths
6,853Sqft
Ocala, Florida, 34480, United States
Offered as a combined estate totaling 11.38 acres across two parcels, this exceptional custom residence is nestled within the prestigious Country Club Farms, this exceptional custom estate offers a rare blend of refined luxury, thoughtful design, and equestrian-friendly living — all just minutes from downtown Ocala, championship golf, the Country Club of Ocala, and top-rated schools.
Michael Polly
$2,099,999
2150 SE 73 LOOP
Ocala, Florida, 34480, United States
Offered as a combined estate totaling 11.38 acres across two parcels, this exceptional custom residence is nestled within the prestigious Country Club Farms, this exceptional custom estate offers a rare blend of refined luxury, thoughtful design, and equestrian-friendly living — all just minutes from downtown Ocala, championship golf, the Country Club of Ocala, and top-rated schools. With bridle trail access woven throughout the community, this property presents a truly rare opportunity to create a private legacy estate in one of Ocala’s most coveted settings. Built with enduring quality and timeless craftsmanship, the residence features 10-foot ceilings, extensive crown molding, solid-core doors throughout, 40-year architectural shingles, surround sound, and an abundance of custom storage and closet space. A private residential elevator connects both levels, offering ease and accessibility while enhancing the home’s sense of quiet luxury. The heart of the home is a beautifully appointed chef’s kitchen, complemented by a butler’s pantry and flowing seamlessly into the formal dining room and an elegant study or library with a gas fireplace, ideal for intimate gatherings or peaceful evenings. The expansive family room offers a second fireplace, while a separate living or game room opens directly to the outdoor entertaining spaces, creating a natural flow between indoor and outdoor living. The primary suite is privately situated on the first floor, creating a serene retreat, and is joined by an additional guest bedroom and full bath on the main level. Upstairs, three additional ensuite bedrooms and a theater room, which may also serve as a playroom, den, or flexible bonus space, provide exceptional comfort and versatility for family and guests alike. Outdoors, the estate transforms into a private resort-style sanctuary. A solar-heated saltwater pool is surrounded by pavered patios, fire pit seating, and screened entertaining areas, all framed by mature landscaping and tranquil views that offer privacy and serenity in every direction. Designed for both luxury and function, the property also includes a four-car garage, a full-house generator, a whole-home water filtration system, and two private wells — one dedicated to irrigation and one servicing the residence. Recent upgrades include three new air conditioning systems in 2024, a new water heater in 2024, a new dishwasher in 2024, a new washer in 2025, and a new dryer in 2024, offering peace of mind and modern efficiency. The property is fully fenced and thoughtfully designed with paddocks, a dog run, and direct bridle trail access, making it ideally suited for equestrian living while remaining just minutes from modern conveniences. This is not simply a home — it is a refined estate where privacy, elegance, and lifestyle converge in perfect harmony.
Read More
Michael Polly
$1,999,987
4Beds
4.2Baths
3,575Sqft
Bonita Springs, Florida, 34134, United States
This well-maintained luxury home features a redesigned kitchen (2014) with premium finishes and an effortless flow into the main living areas. Travertine flooring runs through the main spaces, with porcelain tile in most bedrooms and high ceilings throughout.
Michael Polly
$1,999,987
26372 Mahogany Pointe Court
Bonita Springs, Florida, 34134, United States
This well-maintained luxury home features a redesigned kitchen (2014) with premium finishes and an effortless flow into the main living areas. Travertine flooring runs through the main spaces, with porcelain tile in most bedrooms and high ceilings throughout. Additional features include built-in cabinetry in the great room and den, updated bathroom countertops, wainscoted walls, flooring, complete hurricane protection, two NEW AC systems installed in 2022, and a NEW ROOF in spring of 2025. The outdoor living area is a standout feature, offering an extensive covered lanai, pool, spa, pool bath, and mature tropical landscaping. The home backs to a nature preserve, providing privacy and a quiet setting, along with a partial golf course view from the pool deck. Landscape lighting adds a clean, finished look to the gardens and preserve in the evening. Living in Bonita Bay means access to a wide range of amenities, including a private beach park, full-service marina, five championship golf courses, tennis and pickleball facilities, miles of walking and biking paths, and several beautifully maintained parks and nature preserves. It’s a community known for its lifestyle, natural setting, and top-tier recreational options.
Read More
Michael Polly
$1,999,987
26372 Mahogany Pointe Court
4Beds
4.2Baths
3,575Sqft
$1,999,987
Bonita Springs, Florida, 34134, United States
$1,995,000
3Beds
3Baths
2,032Sqft
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
Incredible Bayfront Living with 150 Feet on Sunset Bay!?Experience coastal luxury in this beautifully renovated 3-bedroom, 3-bath beach home, perfectly positioned on one of Sanibel’s most desirable bayfront settings. With over 150 feet of prime waterfront, enjoy sweeping water views and unforgettable sunsets from nearly every room.
Michael Polly
$1,995,000
2667 Coconut Drive
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
Incredible Bayfront Living with 150 Feet on Sunset Bay!?Experience coastal luxury in this beautifully renovated 3-bedroom, 3-bath beach home, perfectly positioned on one of Sanibel’s most desirable bayfront settings. With over 150 feet of prime waterfront, enjoy sweeping water views and unforgettable sunsets from nearly every room. This serene retreat features an electric fireplace, expansive deck for entertaining, 2-car garage, and a private boat dock with lift—ideal for embracing the island boating lifestyle. Offering exceptional privacy, tranquility, and direct water access, this home delivers the best of relaxed living and coastal adventure. A rare opportunity to own a true slice of paradise on Sunset Bay on Sanibel Island! Dreams really do come true.
Read More
Michael Polly
$1,995,000
2667 Coconut Drive
3Beds
3Baths
2,032Sqft
$1,995,000
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
$1,995,000
3Beds
4,341Sqft
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
Incredible Bayfront Living with 150 Feet on Sunset Bay!?Experience coastal luxury in this beautifully renovated 3-bedroom, 3-bath beach home, perfectly positioned on one of Sanibel’s most desirable bayfront settings. With over 150 feet of prime waterfront, enjoy sweeping water views and unforgettable sunsets from nearly every room.
Michael Polly
$1,995,000
2667 Coconut Dr
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
Incredible Bayfront Living with 150 Feet on Sunset Bay!?Experience coastal luxury in this beautifully renovated 3-bedroom, 3-bath beach home, perfectly positioned on one of Sanibel’s most desirable bayfront settings. With over 150 feet of prime waterfront, enjoy sweeping water views and unforgettable sunsets from nearly every room. This serene retreat features an electric fireplace, expansive deck for entertaining, 2-car garage, and a private boat dock with lift—ideal for embracing the island boating lifestyle. Offering exceptional privacy, tranquility, and direct water access, this home delivers the best of relaxed living and coastal adventure. A rare opportunity to own a true slice of paradise on Sunset Bay on Sanibel Island—dreams really do come true.
Read More
Michael Polly
$1,995,000
3Beds
0.1Baths
2,358Sqft
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
Somerset at the Reef. One of the premier west gulf direct beachfront condo developments and units on Sanibel. The development offers new and updated gulf front pool, tennis, pickleball, landscaping and buildings. Magnificent beach views. Rare opportunity to own a direct gulf front Somerset condo A Building- 1 of just 2 Gulf Front Buildings within Somerset. Convenient West Gulf Drive location.
Michael Polly
$1,995,000
3215 West Gulf Drive #A202
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
Somerset at the Reef. One of the premier west gulf direct beachfront condo developments and units on Sanibel. The development offers new and updated gulf front pool, tennis, pickleball, landscaping and buildings. Magnificent beach views. Rare opportunity to own a direct gulf front Somerset condo A Building- 1 of just 2 Gulf Front Buildings within Somerset. Convenient West Gulf Drive location. Low Density community. 3 bedroom/den option with over 2300 sq ft of livable space. Just 2 units per floor. Spacious Bedrooms, enclosed impact windows and sliders also on lanais offering panoramic vistas. Covered parking, ground level storage. Onsite management and well maintained with strong competent board and association that have assessments competed and paid. Guest parking, grills and a wonderful neighborly environment. The unit is in decorator ready condition.
Read More
Michael Polly
$1,995,000
3215 West Gulf Drive #A202
3Beds
0.1Baths
2,358Sqft
$1,995,000
Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States
$1,995,000
3Beds
2Baths
3,000Sqft
Marco Island, Florida, 34145, United States
Exceptional waterfront home for those who seek both comfort and beauty in a natural setting. This elegant custom-built residence features three bedrooms, two bathrooms, and an office, offering an impressive and spacious layout. Nestled in a quiet residential neighborhood, the home boasts large rooms, high ceilings, and an open floor plan, making it ideal for entertaining.
Michael Polly
$1,995,000
9 Acorn Court
Marco Island, Florida, 34145, United States
Exceptional waterfront home for those who seek both comfort and beauty in a natural setting. This elegant custom-built residence features three bedrooms, two bathrooms, and an office, offering an impressive and spacious layout. Nestled in a quiet residential neighborhood, the home boasts large rooms, high ceilings, and an open floor plan, making it ideal for entertaining. Highlights include a separate dining room, a formal living room, and a family room that seamlessly flows together. The home is adorned with Andersen windows, maple cabinetry, crown molding, and 10-foot sliding doors that enhance the overall ambiance. The split floor plan provides privacy, and you will be greeted by magnificent 10-foot solid wood double doors leading into the expansive master bedroom suite. Outside, the lanai features a grill and prep station, while the lap pool and spa overlook the private dock with a lift—perfect for boating enthusiasts who will appreciate the direct access to open waters within minutes. Offered fully furnished, this home is the ultimate complete package.
Read More
Michael Polly
$1,995,000
9 Acorn Court
3Beds
2Baths
3,000Sqft
$1,995,000
Marco Island, Florida, 34145, United States
$1,975,000
4Beds
4.1Baths
5,195Sqft
Fort Myers, Florida, 33901, United States
Homes like this do not come along, especially in the Historic District off McGregor Boulevard. Custom built, this exceptional residence sits on two full lots and delivers a level of craftsmanship, scale, and quality that is nearly impossible to replicate at today’s cost, at any price.
Michael Polly
$1,975,000
1265 Canterbury Drive
Fort Myers, Florida, 33901, United States
Homes like this do not come along, especially in the Historic District off McGregor Boulevard. Custom built, this exceptional residence sits on two full lots and delivers a level of craftsmanship, scale, and quality that is nearly impossible to replicate at today’s cost, at any price. Offering approximately 5,400 square feet under air and nearly 10,000 square feet total, this residence is substantial, intentional, and beautifully maintained with recent enhancements, including a brand-new roof and media room. From the moment you arrive via the circular driveway and three-car garage, the presence is undeniable. Inside, the home lives large yet refined, anchored by a first-floor primary retreat with oversized walk-in closets and a spa-caliber bath. A standout library/study with custom built-ins, rich wood floors, and its own private courtyard creates a quiet, sophisticated escape rarely found today. Designed for seamless indoor-outdoor living, both the fireplace living room and expansive family room feature zero-corner pocket sliders that completely disappear, opening to a resort-style screened pool and spa with abundant covered lanai space. The outdoor experience is next-level, complete with a bar and grilling area everyone gravitates toward, plus a separate courtyard with fireplace that feels like a private boutique resort. Upstairs, a screened lanai off the media room adds yet another layer of livable luxury. The home continues to impress with a chef’s kitchen, formal dining room built for entertaining, media room, loft/workout space, wine room, butler’s pantry, generous guest suites, generator, and thoughtful details throughout that only a true custom build delivers. Simply put, this home cannot be duplicated for the price being offered. Not on a double lot. Not with this square footage. Not with this level of construction and finish. For a buyer who expects a certain caliber of home, and understands how rare this combination is, This Is A Must-See, Must-Act Opportunity. Homes of this quality, in this location, DO NOT WAIT.
Read More
Michael Polly
$1,975,000
1265 Canterbury Drive
4Beds
4.1Baths
5,195Sqft
$1,975,000
Fort Myers, Florida, 33901, United States
$1,899,500
4Beds
3Baths
2,654Sqft
Cape Coral, Florida, 33904, United States
Experience waterfront living at its finest in this impeccably maintained, like-new custom home with panoramic views overlooking 1.5 miles of open river.
Michael Polly
$1,899,500
2506 SE 28th Street
Cape Coral, Florida, 33904, United States
Experience waterfront living at its finest in this impeccably maintained, like-new custom home with panoramic views overlooking 1.5 miles of open river. Perfectly situated in a prime location with southeastern exposure, this property offers both luxury and comfort in a resort-style setting! Step through the impressive 8-ft double doors into a naturally light-filled, open-concept great room with soaring coffered ceilings, tile flooring throughout, and dramatic 10-ft corner pocket sliders that fully retract for a seamless indoor-outdoor living experience. The expansive lanai and custom saltwater pool/spa area are truly an entertainer’s dream heated with gas, and complete with Pentair automation, programmable LED lighting, and a full outdoor kitchen with built-in grill—all framed by a panoramic screen enclosure that showcases breathtaking sunrises over the river. The heart of the home is a chef’s dream kitchen, featuring a large center island, gas cooktop, tons of storage with soft-close custom cabinetry, and a massive walk-in pantry. Entertain with ease in the elegant indoor bar area, complete with wine cooler and 200-bottle wine storage. The luxurious master suite is a private retreat with riverviews from your oversized whirlpool tub, a walk-in double shower, and spa-like finishes throughout. Every detail of this home has been thoughtfully designed—from the surround sound system, Cat-6 cabling, and whole-home surge protection, to the four wall-mounted big screen TVs and indoor laundry room with built-in ironing board and tub sink. Car enthusiasts will love the climate-controlled 1,000 sqft garage, capable of housing up to four vehicles comfortably. The gorgeous tropically landscaped yard features exotic palms and fruit trees, with a newer (2016) seawall, and a spacious concrete dock—ready for your waterfront adventures! Additional highlights include: 250-gallon propane tank, Six-zone audio system, Pocketed and 90-degree sliders for open-air living, and Easy access to Fort Myers via the Midpoint Bridge. This rare riverfront gem offers the perfect blend of luxury, functionality, and natural beauty. Whether you’re seeking a serene retreat or an entertainer’s paradise, this home delivers on every level. Don’t miss your opportunity to own a slice of paradise—schedule your private showing today!
Read More
Michael Polly
$1,899,500
2506 SE 28th Street
4Beds
3Baths
2,654Sqft
$1,899,500
Cape Coral, Florida, 33904, United States
$1,875,000
3Beds
2.1Baths
2,852Sqft
Cape Coral, Florida, 33904, United States
“Turnkey” takes on an entirely new meaning in this exceptional waterfront residence. With more than 300,000 in owner upgrades, this home is truly move in ready—bring only your suitcase and start enjoying the luxury of Gulf access living.
Michael Polly
$1,875,000
4226 SE 6th Place
Cape Coral, Florida, 33904, United States
“Turnkey” takes on an entirely new meaning in this exceptional waterfront residence. With more than 300,000 in owner upgrades, this home is truly move in ready—bring only your suitcase and start enjoying the luxury of Gulf access living. Offering 3 bedrooms plus a den, a saltwater infinity edge pool, and a rare 4 car garage, this 3,000 square foot home blends sophistication, comfort, and unmatched functionality. Waterfront Excellence is just the beginning. Enjoy Gulf access and three boat lifts—16,000 lb with canopy, 12,000 lb, and 10,000 lb—perfect for everything from a sport boat to kayaks. All lifts were installed in 2024. Smart Home Living - the entire property is powered by a Crestron Home Automation System, giving you control over security, camera’s, and audio/visual features, including wired access points throughout. Elegant Interior Designs are everywhere in this home. Enter through curved wrought iron doors into soaring 14’ coffered ceilings and beautifully curated designer finishes—tile flooring, beadboard accents, barn doors, and solid core interior doors. The floor plan maximizes livable space including a walk in pantry, coffee bar, and spacious laundry room. The kitchen is designed for both culinary excellence and gathering with loved ones. Highlights include an expansive center island, gas cooktop powered by a 150 lb propane tank, high-end Miele appliances, insta-hot water and reverse osmosis system, plus custom cabinetry and a dedicated coffee bar. The main living area flows seamlessly from the kitchen. Enjoy views of the water and your stunning outdoor space from the family room as you enjoy your 98-inch television. Need to relax or retire for the evening? The split bedroom layout ensures privacy, and each suite features its own mini split AC system for personalized comfort. All bathrooms include comfort height toilets with bidet and auto flush systems. The primary suite is a retreat of its own, offering volume ceilings, a spa inspired bathroom with a walk around shower and soaking tub, and a large designer walk in closet with natural light. The outdoor space is an entertainer’s dream. Multiple seating and dining areas overlook the infinity edge pool and waterfront. Here you’ll enjoy a double Napoleon gas grill, infrared sauna, a pool bath just steps away, and the gas fire pit for evening relaxation. Don’t forget about the 4 car garage which is climate controlled with two mini split AC units, epoxy flooring, custom tool cabinetry, a utility sink, and a large storage closet. The home also includes a 2016 roof, 2024 AC and mini split systems, impact windows and doors, electric Storm Smart screens on the lanai, whole house portable generator which can run all the mini-splits should the power go out. This stunning property redefines “turnkey” with thoughtful upgrades, luxurious finishes, and every amenity needed for effortless waterfront living. You are now home!
Read More
Michael Polly
$1,875,000
4226 SE 6th Place
3Beds
2.1Baths
2,852Sqft
$1,875,000
Cape Coral, Florida, 33904, United States
Favorite this home
Enter your email to continue
or
By signing in you agree to UniqueHomes Terms of Use and Privacy Policy